?

Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry | Next Entry

Border Control

I think this essay by crasch deserves to be read and linked to.

http://crasch.livejournal.com/460112.html

Comments

kmo
Oct. 1st, 2006 03:52 pm (UTC)
Re: Intuition pump
We are disucssing the issues raised in crasch's essay, yes?

Crash wrote:
Advocates for immigration restrictions use the term "border control" to refer to restricting immigration across the U.S.'s national border. But the national border is just one of many borders. There are also state borders, and county borders, and city borders. If you own land, the borders of your property are defined by your property lines. Even your car and body have borders.

I'm less interested in why you would want to live in a community that is different from you than in the question of what right you think you have to impose your presence upon a community that would deny you admitance.

Have I answered your questions?
venusflytrap
Oct. 1st, 2006 04:05 pm (UTC)
Re: Intuition pump
a sense of entitlement, i suppose. mostly powered by the almighty dollar.

you ask..what right i have to impose my presence upon a community that would deny my admitance? i dont get it? i think it boils down to ownership rather than the feelings of the people around me. if a community denies me admitance, i CANT be there before i demand the RIGHT to 'impose' my presence, no? one cannot 'impose' oneself when one isnt 'present'...logically, that is...

no, you havent really answered my questions. your position isnt very clear. to me.
kmo
Oct. 1st, 2006 04:47 pm (UTC)
Re-focus
no, you havent really answered my questions. your position isnt very clear. to me.

Yes. That's the sense I get.

To refocus: Should every community within a nation state be governed according to rules established at the national level without regard for local differences or the preferences of local communities? I answer "No," to this question. crasch formulated the question in terms of who should be allowed to cross the border but then asked why focus only on the national border. My interest in this question does not relate exclusively or specifically to the question of immigration.

The United States constitution lays out a very few and well-defined roles for the Federal Government and explicitly reserves decision-making authority over all other matters to the states and to the people. Over the course of the 20th Century and two World Wars, the US Federal Government has increased the scope of its authority and systematically undermined the authority of the states to regulate themselves according to local conditions, concerns, and cultural considerations.

One symptom of the inflated role of the federal government at the expense of local communities appears when we talk about "border control." The discussion automatically gravitates to the national borders, but what about the rights of individuals and communities to make decissions about regions defined by other boarders? State borders, for instance, or the border of a gated community. If someone has successfully passed through the discrimination exercised at the national border, do they then enjoy carte blanche to cross any border within the Nation? Does no other entity other than the Federal government have any say about the integrity of its borders?

You seem to recognize the rights of private property. Let's take a moment and appreciate this point of aggreement between us. Now, where do we stand on the question of county borders? I live in a dry county. I may not, under penalty of law, make, buy or sell alcoholic beverages in Benton county? Does Benton county enjoy the right to prohibit an activity that Federal law allows? So far, it would seem so. Does Humbolt county enjoy the right to allow an activity that Federal law prohibits. So far, it would seem not. Why?

If you still do not understand my concerns and my interest in crasch's essay, please ask further questions. I make the judgement that you posed many of your questions so far with rhetorical intent. I would encourage you to ask genuine clarificatory questions. If you do, I will answer them, though I will be signing off for the remainder of the day now, so don't take my short term lack of response for anything other than my having moved away from my internet connection for the day.

Latest Month

August 2017
S M T W T F S
  12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031  

Tags

Page Summary

Powered by LiveJournal.com
Designed by Ideacodes